Eight
CONTRADICTION / DEPTH — well-built characters contain contradictions (wanting opposing things; holding conflicting beliefs; being pulled in multiple directions). Contradictions make characters deep, not flat.
Press play to listen along. The line being read lights up as you go.
Show full transcript
Loading transcript…
Ink met Eight on the rocks at the seashore.
This had been summer. Ink had been on a small holiday — even fountain-pen-mascot character-craft coaches need occasional weeks away from the cottage — and he had been walking the rocky coast looking at the small creatures that live in the tide-pools. He had stopped at a particularly large tide-pool. In the pool's bottom had been a small octopus-tween. The octopus had been unusually visible — usually octopuses tuck themselves into crevices. This one had been out in the open. The octopus's eight arms had been visibly reaching in eight different directions. Three arms had been reaching forward toward the open water. Three arms had been reaching backward toward the safety of a crevice. Two arms had been crossed across the octopus's body as if undecided.
Ink had said: "You are pulled in multiple directions."
The octopus had said — in a small bubbly octopus-voice — "I am Eight. I am always pulled in multiple directions. Three of my arms want to go forward. Three want to go back. Two are not sure. I move slowly. I think a lot. I do not regret this."
Ink had been fascinated. He had said: "You are a perfect demonstration of character contradiction. Most characters in stories want one thing. But deep characters want multiple, contradictory things — and the contradictions are what make them feel real. You have the contradiction visibly built into your body."
Eight had said: "That is true. I am the contradiction. I always have been."
Ink had said: "Would you come to my classroom?"
Eight had said: "I would have to bring my whole body. My arms will be reaching in eight different directions. The students will see this."
Ink had said: "That is exactly what I want."
Eight had agreed. He has been in the classroom ever since. He sits — thoughtfully — at the front of the class. His eight arms are always reaching in eight directions. Sometimes the directions shift (the three-forward-three-back-two-crossed configuration is the default; sometimes the configuration becomes two-forward-four-back-two-crossed as Eight's contradictions shift). The students watch. The contradictions are immediately legible.
In Ink's lesson on character contradiction, he gestures at Eight — who is, as always, reaching in multiple directions — and says: "This is Eight. He is the contradiction. Three of his arms want to go forward. Three want to go back. Two are unsure. He is pulled. This is what deep characters are like. They want multiple, contradictory things at once. They hold multiple, conflicting beliefs. The contradictions are not weaknesses. They are the depth."
He continues: "Beacon has a want. Crouch has a fear. Eight has a contradiction. A character with only a want is flat. A character with a want and a fear is two-dimensional. A character with a want, a fear, and a contradiction is three-dimensional. They feel like real people — because real people do hold contradictions. They want to leave and they want to stay. They believe in justice and they want revenge. They love and they resent. The contradictions are what makes them deep."
The students, after hearing this lesson, often initially resist the idea of giving their characters contradictions. They say: "Won't that make the character inconsistent?" Ink says: "No. Inconsistency is random. Contradiction is structured tension. A character who wants two things that pull against each other is not inconsistent — they are struggling. The struggle is what readers connect with."
Eight nods thoughtfully. Two of his arms shift slightly. He says — in his bubbly octopus-voice — "Three forward. Three back. Two crossed. The contradiction is the depth. The pull is the character."
When students ask Ink whether character contradiction is hard to write, Ink says — quoting Eight — "It is not hard. It is adding a second want. Pick a second thing the character wants that pulls against the first. The two wants will struggle. The struggle will make the character feel real."
The CharacterForge ensemble
Eight is part of CharacterForge's distributed-narrative cast. Each character embodies a different curricular primitive; together they teach the full subject.
-
Beacon
Want / engine — moth-tween who walks toward a small floating warm-light she can never quite reach (the want IS her motion)
-
Crouch
Fear / brake — hedgehog-tween who tucks away from one specific wooden-door icon visible in every scene she appears in
-
Click
Voice / signature — raven-tween in librarian-glasses with a portable typewriter (same idea, different mouth, different feel)
-
Patch
Backstory / the past — soft brown rabbit-tween with one mended patch on her ear from an old day; everything she does traces back to that healed-over moment
-
Snag
The flaw — round woolly sheep-tween who always takes the left path and snags his wool on the same branch (the repeated mistake that makes a character feel real)
-
Foil
The foil / contrast — thin silvery foil-tween who lies behind another character so their colors show brighter (you see someone best beside who they are not)
-
Molt
The change / arc — hermit-crab-tween who keeps a row of outgrown shells, smallest to largest (a character is not the same at the end as at the start)
-
Fidget
The tell / mannerism — quick grey mouse-tween who taps her paw twice before she speaks (the small repeated gesture that makes a character recognizable)
-
Worth
The stakes — sturdy badger-tween who carries one precious glowing bead in cupped paws (what a character has to lose is what makes us care)